Thousand Oaks
- Ameci Pizza and Pasta: A long-running local favorite with New York style pizza, with locations in Thousand Oaks, Newbury Park and Westlake Village.
- Winners Pizza (1805 E. Thousand Oaks Blvd.): Regular and heart-shaped pizzas, plus gluten-free and cauliflower crust options.
- Butler's Pizza (1655 Thousand Oaks Blvd.): New York style pizza, including gluten-free options.
Newbury Park
- Tony's New York Pizza (Kimber Plaza): A neighborhood staple that has served Newbury Park for decades.
- Boney Mountain Pizza Company (Wendy Drive): A sports bar with a focus on California style pizza, good for game day.
- Magma Pizzeria (Conejo Gateway Plaza): A newcomer that opened in September 2026.
Westlake Village
- Prince St. Pizza (Shoppes at Westlake Village): Opened in July 2025, serving Sicilian squares and Neapolitan pizzas by the slice or whole pie.
- Ameci Pizza and Pasta (Lindero Canyon Road): A dependable family option.
Agoura Hills
- Two Doughs Pizza Co. (Whizin Market Square): Thin crust sourdough pizzas and Sicilian thick crust, with gluten-free options.
- Pizza Nosh: The only vegetarian, kosher pizza place in the Conejo Valley.
Why this matters if you're moving to the Conejo Valley
When buyers choose a neighborhood, they are choosing a daily routine: where they grab dinner on a Friday night, where the kids go after a game, which spot becomes the family tradition. I love helping clients discover the local places that make a community feel like home.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best pizza in Thousand Oaks? It depends on your taste. Ameci, Winners and Butler's are established local options, and I'd love to hear your favorite.
Is there gluten-free or vegetarian pizza in the Conejo Valley? Yes. Winners, Butler's and Two Doughs offer gluten-free options, and Pizza Nosh in Agoura Hills is vegetarian and kosher.
What's new in local pizza? Magma Pizzeria opened in Newbury Park in September 2026, and Prince St. Pizza arrived in Westlake Village in 2025.
Moving to the Conejo Valley and want local recommendations along with your home search? I'm Karen Sandvig with Coldwell Banker. Reach me at karensandvighomes.com or 818-941-7437. DRE01507450
